Indian Bill To Ban Cryptocurrency Excluded From Winter Parliament Agenda

The latest news indicates that the government of India will not be deliberating on the cryptocurrency bill during the winter session of parliament as was previously planned. On Nov. 14 2019, the Lok Sabha – India’s lower house of parliament – released the tentative list of bills which the government is expected to introduce and pass during the upcoming winter session.

While the “Personal Data Protection Bill” is included in the session agenda, the “Banning of Cryptocurrency & Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill 2019” is missing.  

Good News as Crypto Bill Delayed

India’s government has been considering the need for passing the crypto bill to ban cryptocurrencies in the country. In August 2019, the government told the country’s supreme court that the bill may be introduced in the winter session of parliament.

However, the lower house of India’s parliament published the agenda for the winter session that does not include the cryptocurrency bill. The winter session begins on 18th November and ends on 13th December.

The crypto community welcomes the delay of the cryptocurrency ban. The CEO of local cryptocurrency exchange Pockebits – Sohail Merchant – said that the draft bill to ban cryptocurrencies is not on the agenda for the parliament winter session.  

He considered this as a relief for now. But he emphasized that now it is time for the local crypto community to come together and present their case to the regulators.  

Also, Wazirx crypto exchange CEO – Nischal Shetty – regarded this as great news for the cryptocurrency ecosystem of India. He described the move by the India government not to include the draft bill to ban cryptocurrencies in the upcoming parliament session as great. He sees the India government as listening since they are not rushing to ban crypto in the country.

The Legislative Process   

The bill seeking to ban all digital currencies except state-owned cryptocurrencies was made by the IMC (Interministerial Committee) chaired by Subhash Chandra Garg – the Former Secretary of the Ministry of Economic Affairs. The bill was submitted to the Finance Ministry in February 2019 and made public in July.

Following the government’s intention to introduce this bill in the parliament’s winter session, the supreme court postponed the hearing of all petitions associated with the country’s cryptocurrency policies until January next year.  

India is among the five BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) thinking to launch a new cryptocurrency to enable cross-border money transfer between the member nations.

Renewed Push for Community Unity

Since the cryptocurrency bill was made public, the crypto community in India has been actively campaigning for the government to reconsider the recommendations. The community emphasizes that the bill is flawed.

For example, Sohail Merchant – Pockebits CEO – urged all stakeholders within the crypto industry to forget emotions and competition, but to echo their thoughts with a single voice.

Earlier this month, several cryptocurrency stakeholders gathered at an event identified as “Unwind with Crypto”. The meeting aimed to bring all the important stakeholders within the crypto industry together and develop a stronger global community.

The pioneers of the blockchain and crypto industry attended the meeting. Among them include crypto Kannon’s Kashif Raza who mentioned that it is unfortunate that despite the utmost efforts of the crypto community, the Central Bank of India still appears confused concerning the widespread power of crypto assets.

Meanwhile, investors in the industry have widely criticized India’s potential to ban cryptocurrencies. In October 2019, Tim Draper – billionaire venture capitalist – called on Prime minster Narendra Modi to rethink the country’s hostile stance of cryptocurrency. He mentioned that India is leaving itself vulnerable by trying to ban cryptocurrencies.

A report shows that India risks facing loses of an estimated $12.9 billion if it bans cryptocurrencies.  

Image via Shutterstock

Analysis: Here is What the New Crypto Bill Mean for the Blockchain Ecosystem?

Proponents of the cryptocurrency industry have been requesting a comprehensive crypto bill for some time. Thanks to the bipartisan efforts of Senators Cynthia Lummis (R-Wyo.) and Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), there are proposals on the ground for lawmakers to ponder.

The new Crypto Bill is coming at a time when the growth of the cryptocurrency ecosystem is becoming more convoluted, with investors’ protection concerns emanating from various scams and frauds targeting the average investor. The Bill seeks to address so many of the grey areas in the digital currency ecosystem, including taxation, regulatory oversight, and the role of stablecoins, to mention a few.

The new crypto bill, if approved, will set the U.S. on a clearer pedestal with respect to dealings with digital assets, which have largely come to stay. 

Chris Terry, BPSAA Board Member and V.P. Enterprise Solutions at SmartFi spoke to Blockchain.News that he believes if this Bill passed as is it would be wonderful for the crypto industry and would clearly set the United States in a leadership position.

“What is interesting about the ‘Lummis-Gillibrand Responsible Financial Innovation Act; are the things that most of the press is not talking about, like Section 505 – your right to own your own keys or Section 502 Definition of Source code.  They discuss Defi in Section 805 and even the Digital Yuan in Section 603. This shows that these two Senators have a deep knowledge of cryptocurrency and blockchain technology.  Quite honestly I was very impressed with the Bill. The challenge will be getting the rest of Congress to act on it.  “

Highlights of the Crypto Bill

Described as a “landmark bill” by Sen Gillibrand, the crypto bill has a number of features, including its definition of crypto as either securities or commodities. Over time, American crypto investors and stakeholders are often torn concerning how they should classify whatever product they are developing, a move that will determine which regulator they will be subjected to.

With the new Bill, all token issuers will get clarity on the products they release, drawing on outright knowledge of the “purpose of the asset and the rights or powers it conveys to the consumer.” The Bill exclusively identifies the majority of digital currencies, including pioneer Bitcoin (BTC), and Ethereum (ETH), the largest smart contract protocol, as commodities. 

As commodities, the Bill will seek to confer enormous powers on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as the major overseer of the emerging industry. Crypto proponents, in their clamour over the years, have often requested that a new regulatory body be established to identify the industry’s intricacies properly. While the Bill is not open access to a new body entirely, its recognition of CFTC is one big step toward stemming all forms of confusion.

Scams and frauds are almost always interwoven with the crypto industry. Several reports of scams have bankrupted trading exchanges like the case of MtGox and QuadrigaCx. While these examples may not necessarily have a direct bearing as the exchanges were based out of the U.S., most serve U.S. customers.

For those exchanges incorporated in the U.S., the new Bill has provisions for the custody of digital assets in the case of bankruptcy or mishap leading to the incapacitation of the trading platform. 

There was a major uproar last year when there was a contention about using the word crypto brokers when the taxation allowance of entities in the digital currency ecosystem was being considered for financing President Joe Biden’s infrastructure bill. The new Bill also defined crypto brokers in a bid to protect wallet service providers and miners from shielding them from certain tax reporting requirements.

Another major highlight of the Bill is that it exempts transactions of $200 and below from taxing while also demanding a “100% reserve, asset type and detailed disclosure requirements for all payment stablecoin issuers.” 

With venture funding a major trend in the crypto ecosystem of today, the new Bill also requests data transparency and disclosures across the board. 

Styliana Charalambous, Head of Investments & Market Research at Pure, spoke to Blockchain.News through an emailed statement. Charalambous commented about the consequences that the Bill also requires certain disclosures to the SEC from companies that raise funds through digital asset sales.

“The approach would ensure that market participants and our securities regulatory community receive detailed and accurate disclosures about those digital assets that are widely traded, but in a manner that encourages innovation.”

Broader Implications of the Crypto Bill

The development of the Bill may not serve the interest of a few stakeholders with extraneous demands, but if approved, it will have a broad impact in the United States and beyond.

“The Bill should also have a calming effect on investors’ fears regarding a regulatory clampdown on certain projects. Projects not yet sufficiently decentralized would be required to file minimum disclosures with the SEC that will be less burdensome than current procedures, but still helpful to investors,” Styliana added, “Once that project becomes fully decentralized, those reporting requirements would end, and compliance costs reduced. On the global scene, this would also allow cryptocurrency exchanges to feel more comfortable with listing projects where the cryptocurrency associated has real utility.”

Beyond the U.S., many countries are jostling to step up their game by providing adequate regulatory oversight to the crypto ecosystem. In fact, the recent collapse of Terra’s algorithmic stablecoin has notably fast-tracked proceedings that have led to the introduction of a comprehensive stablecoin regulation in Japan, the first country to do so.

With the U.S. crypto bill, innovations from the Web3.0 world will not only be fostered. More countries may eventually throw their weight behind the innovative crypto ecosystem and choose not to miss out on the innovations the space heralds, as Galymzhan Pirmatov, the Chairman of the National Bank of Kazakhstan recently noted. 

Exit mobile version