Zcash-Commissioned Research Find Cybercriminals Prefer Bitcoin Over Other Cryptocurrencies

Independent research commissioned by the Electric Coin Company (ECC), the parent firm of privacy-focused cryptocurrency Zcash, concluded cybercriminals are much likely to use Bitcoin over other digital assets. 

Bitcoin dominated by illicit activities

Rand Corporation, an independent, US government-accredited research lab, was hired by Zooko Wilcox, the creator of Zcash and chairman of ECC as a third-party security organization to uncover critical lapses in the coin’s protocol. 

Wilcox commissioned the research after speculation on social media about Zcash’s use in criminal organizations, such as the Dark Web and illegal money laundering outfits. 

But Rand’s conclusions mean naysayers have been answered. The firm discovered no lapses in Zcash, not found any link with criminals opting for the privacy-centric token ahead of other options. Instead, Rand noted criminals may not even understand Zcash’s zk-snarks technology at all. 

The 65-page long report focussed on three major aspects — money laundering, terrorism financing, and the illegal trade of banned goods and services — concluding “no evidence” of any illicit use of Zcash. 

Cryptocurrencies have long powered the dark corners of the internet. The now-defunct Silk Road, an illicit marketplace, incorporated digital assets as a payment method back in 2010.  Federal authorities nabbed millions in dollars worth of Bitcoin during a high-profile raid in 2014, post-which dark web sites moved to privacy-centric currencies like Monero. 

Zcash only 1 percent on dark web

Zcash’s creation in 2014, followed by its subsequent popularity, led to internet critics calling the token a facilitator of illicit trade, with even major news outlets providing negative publicity to the ECC. 

But Wilcox and ECC may breathe easy now. Rand’s findings made clear the token is not dominant on the dark web. Instead, it has a minor presence and is not preferred ahead of Bitcoin or Monero. 

However, the report added that one percent of illegal websites accepted Zcash as a means-of-payment. 59 percent took Bitcoin, 27 percent accepted Monero, 12 percent accepted  Ethereum and 1 percent even took Litecoin. 

However, the Zcash-commissioned report does throw up some conflicting peculiarities. 

A 2018 report by Europol concluded terrorist organization ISIS used Zcash for criminal financing and paying its vendors for weapons. Another firm, Chainalysis, which specializes in on-chain analytics, also reported Zcash’s popularity on the dark web. Blockchain.News also reported on a major bug in the protocol in 2019 that challenged its premise of total privacy. 

Image via Shutterstock

Monero: Deep Dive

Monero (XMR) was the first cryptocurrency of its kind to offer advancements in privacy and fungibility.The introduction of Bitcoin as a way of transacting discreetly led many people into a false sense of security regarding the anonymity of their transactions. As public blockchains are available to view by anyone with an internet connection, transactions on the Bitcoin blockchain contain data regarding the transaction amount, as well as both sender and receiver wallet addresses. This makes it easy to trace Bitcoin or Ethereum transactions using a blockchain scanner.

In countries that are subject to capital controls, the ability to make cross-border payments and remittances anonymously is crucial. During times of economic uncertainty, restricting the flow of money can be devastating, especially when the value of a national currency is declining. Financial freedom and privacy are important as citizens are faced with withdrawal limits and censorship of non-national currencies. Those living under an authoritarian dictatorship might wish to conceal their wealth and spending habits from governments for fear of confiscation.

Privacy coins also present an attractive prospect to businesses operating on the blockchain that wish to have the specifics of their capital allocations, holdings, and expenditures concealed. In business, if a supplier can see that a merchant holds a significant amount of Bitcoin, this could encourage the supplier to demand steeper prices, putting the merchant at a disadvantage.

Monero (XMR) was the first cryptocurrency of its kind to offer advancements in privacy and fungibility. The Monero protocol is automatically updated every 6 months, eliminating much of the controversy surrounding updates to other popular blockchain protocols.

History

Monero first began in 2013 when developer Nicolas van Saberhagen released the CryptoNote whitepaper, gaining attention from high profile figures in the fields of blockchain and cryptography.

CryptoNote was not a huge success, however, it led to a new cryptocurrency named “Bytecoin”. Bytecoin had some success, but the project was ultimately finished when allegations arose regarding the manipulation of the circulating supply by developers.

In April 2014, “Bitmonero” was launched, but would later be hard forked and renamed simply to “Monero”. Monero was maintained by Riccardo Spagni, known in the community as “Fluffypony”, until 2019, when Spagni took a step back from maintenance, with long-time contributor “Snipa” taking the helm thereafter.

XMR is the native Monero token, which is generated in a similar way to other cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin. The proof-of-work consensus algorithm incentivizes miners to confirm transactions and produce new blocks before adding them to the blockchain.

Some of the key privacy features of Monero are:

Fungibility

Multiple Key System

Stealth Addresses

Ring Signatures

RingCT

Fungibility

Fungibility refers to the interchangeability of an asset and how easily divisible it is. For example, USD or BTC are both fungible, as a dollar in your pocket or a bitcoin in your wallet will spend in the same way as any other dollar or Bitcoin. If you lend someone $10, it doesn’t matter that they repay you with a different $10 bill.

The issue with the fungibility of cryptocurrencies is when funds are used for nefarious activities. If funds were obtained as the result of a hack or a scam, this may go unnoticed by the holder, however, these funds could be blacklisted by major exchanges, having tracked the path of the transaction using a block scanner.

Multiple Key System

Monero’s multiple key system uses sophisticated cryptography to obfuscate transactions and user identity. The multiple key system consists of both public and private “view” and “spend” keys.

Stealth Addresses

Another key element of Monero’s privacy is stealth addresses, which enable the sender to random one-time addresses for transactions on behalf of the intended recipient. The recipient can publish a single address while still having incoming transactions assigned to unique addresses on the blockchain. This means that only the sender and the receiver can establish exactly where a payment was sent.

Ring Signatures

Ring Signatures is a process used to further obfuscate the origin of transactions by mixing information from one transaction with the data from other transactions, before being added to the blockchain. With Ring Signatures, Monero mixes 11 signatures in total, adding another layer of privacy and anonymity.

RingCT

The 2017 release of Ring Confidential Transactions made it possible for users to conceal the value amount of a Monero transaction. RingCT adds multiple inputs and outputs to each transaction to make it extremely difficult to identify the addresses of senders and recipients.

Although XMR is often traded and used as a speculative investment, it should be noted that XMR does not have a fixed supply like Bitcoin. From May 2022, the scheduled block rewards will be set at 0.6 XMR per block, but newly minted XMR will not cease to be printed under the Monero software rules, with 18.4 million XMR estimated to be in circulation by this time.

With over 500 developers contributing to the Monero project, making fast and cost-efficient payments on the blockchain with near-absolute anonymity and privacy is a game-changer if you live in a country that imposes harsh capital controls.

Due to the advanced privacy and anonymity features of Monero however, it has been used by hackers to facilitate extortion and poses an even bigger threat to traditional finance than Bitcoin. In 2019, Bitpay ceased trading of Monero due to fears that it could be used in money laundering. Despite this, US authorities claimed this month that they are now able to trace illicit Monero transactions.

The Monero team is currently working on the Kovri project, which aims to hide the IP address of users to further anonymize their transactions. Along with Zcash and Dash, Monero is a pioneer in the privacy coin space, pushing anonymity privacy to the next level within the cryptocurrency space.

Europol Cybercrime Report Identifies Monero, Zcash, Dash and Privacy Wallets as Emerging ‘Top Threats’

Europol assessed the new developments in cybercrime in relation to the COVID-19 pandemic and identified certain cryptocurrency wallets and dark web marketplaces as top threats.

Privacy coins increasingly used in crime

According to the report, privacy-enhancing wallets have emerged as a top threat, due to the rise in popularity of privacy coins. Privacy enhancing coins such as Monero, Zcash, and Dash were named in the assessment for increasingly being leveraged as payment methods on the dark web. Per Europol’s Internet Organised Crime Threat Assessment (IOCTA) report of 2020:

“Monero is gradually becoming the most established privacy coin for dark web transactions, followed by Zcash and Dash.”

Other altcoins that have gained more traction on dark web marketplaces include Ethereum and Litecoin, but the preferred payment method was still allocated to Bitcoin. This is mainly due to the mainstream cryptocurrency’s reputation and mass adoption, among other things.  

Privacy-focused wallets and dark web networks

In addition to favouring hardware wallets for private key and crypto storage, cybercriminals have also increasingly relied on “privacy-enhanced wallet services using coinjoin concepts” and centralized mixers to launder and store their crypto funds. Coinjoin protocols typically operate by merging different transactions originating from non-related users into one transaction. In the Europol report, popular cryptocurrency wallets using this concept included the Wasabi and Samurai wallets. Although these wallets do not completely erase the trail of the transaction, it makes cryptocurrency tracing a lot harder.

As for the preferred dark web protocol, the Tor network remained the most popular choice among criminals. However, an increased interest directed towards decentralized privacy-focused platforms has been observed this year. The report stated:

“The emergence of decentralised privacy-oriented platforms is not a new phenomenon in the Darkweb ecosystem, but they have started to increase interest over the last year.”

Criminals have increasingly resorted to such platforms to sell illicit goods, with OpenBazaar leading the pact as a “high priority threat.” The network was said to have marketed its services through its mobile platform Haven, which has already been downloaded thousands of times on Android.

The Europol report echoes an assessment the agency released in June that indicated that $50 million in Bitcoin had been deposited in Wasabi wallets, with 30% originating from dark web markets.

Most crypto transactions are not related to cybercrime

However, according to data from Europol, although the level of cybercrime has significantly grown, “the legitimate use of cryptocurrencies grew at a much faster rate.”

According to the report, though cryptocurrencies have facilitated payments for all sorts of cybercrime, ranging from sextortion, ransomware, data theft, and even COVID-19 related scams this year, data assessing the year 2019 indicates that the percentage of cryptocurrency transactions linked to cybercrime still translates to only 1.1% of total transactions. 

Privacy Coins Monero, Dash, and Zcash to be Delisted on Bittrex, Dash Unhappy with Decision

Bittrex will be removing privacy coins Monero, Dash, and Zcash from its trading platform soon.

The announcement explained that effective on January 15, 2021, Dash, Grin, Monero, and Zcash trading pairs will be removed from the platform. Although no further explanations have been given by the cryptocurrency exchange to justify the delisting, many have hypothesized that this may be a move to ensure that the trading platform is compliant with cryptocurrency regulations, such as know-your-customer (KYC) and anti-money laundering (AML) policies.

Bittrex may have opted to play on the safe side, with regulators increasingly seeking to investigate privacy coins and their involvement in cybercrime. Privacy coins have long been attractive to criminals for their ability to obfuscate transactions, the amount sent digitally, the wallet address, and the identity of both the sender and the receiver.

Dash bites back

Upon the announcement that Bittrex will delist it, Dash has however commented and claimed that its privacy coin was no more private than the biggest cryptocurrency by market cap, Bitcoin. Through its official account, Dash tweeted:

“From a technical standpoint, Dash’s privacy functionality is no greater than Bitcoin’s, making the label of ‘privacy coin’ a misnomer for Dash. We have reached out to @BittrexExchange to request a meeting with their compliance team. Hopefully this will be rectified soon.”

Crypto regulations in the US tightens

Bittrex’s decision to delist privacy coins comes at a time when the cryptocurrency industry has increasingly been scrutinized by lawmakers struggling to regulate such a budding and dynamic sector. The US Treasury Department has recently issued an announcement proposing new KYC guidelines for cryptocurrency transactions.

The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) has suggested that unhosted wallets should be monitored and cryptocurrency transactions should be compliant with traditional AML laws for fiat.

Exchanges in the US may be looking to avoid sanctions, especially now, as a critical eye has increasingly been directed towards the crypto sector. Recently, the Securities and Exchange Commission made a bold move and slapped Ripple with a lawsuit for selling unregistered securities through XRP. The lawsuit was enough to make XRP’s price drastically plummet, sending the cryptocurrency’s market value down by more than 50%.  

Huobi to Delist Monero and Privacy Tokens on Regulatory Account

Huobi Global has unveiled its plans to delist privacy tokens, counting Monero (XMR), Dash (DSH), Decred (DCR), Firo (FIRO), Verge (XVG), Zcash (ZEC) and Horizen (ZEN) as the digital assets that will be affected.

The delisting process starts today as all deposit support for the cryptocurrencies has been halted. Huobi said its users who still have some funds in any of these digital assets would have up to September 19 to liquidate their positions into their spot wallets.

According to the exchange, any user who did not exit their respective trade position by then will see the trades automatically closed for them by the Huobi and credited into their spot wallet.

The delisting of these privacy coins can be attributed to mounting regulatory pressures and the failure of the coins to comply with their internal compliance policies. Effectively, the delisting of these tokens is supported by the exchange’s Token Management Rules of which Article 17(16) provides for delisting if “The token is a privacy token, does not support offline signatures, or its node source codes are not open-sourced”.

While Huobi, one of the major global digital currency trading platforms, did not ascertain whether the crackdown moves on the privacy coins were based on its compliance efforts from a request from a regulatory body in the regions it currently plies its trade, the firm sure wants to stay on the good books of these market watchdogs.

Huobi has faced some backlash from some regulators in the past year and has been asked to move its business away from Thailand. Despite this, the exchange has been making targeted efforts to enter the US market, with its subsidiary receiving the Money Service Business license from the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), as reported by Blockchain.News back in July.

With the scrutiny on privacy coins building up, Huobi believes it’s high time it delisted the coins.

Exit mobile version